Dani Rotstein and the Jewish history hiding in plain sight in Palma

Dani Rotstein moved from New York to Mallorca for a new adventure. Finding the island’s Jewish community changed the direction of his life. Vicki McLeod joins him in Palma to talk about heritage, belonging and making Jewish culture accessible to more people.

Dani Rotstein smiling at the camera while holding an orange in Palma

I’m around the corner from Plaça Major in Palma, only a few steps from Carrer del Sindicat, but I have never properly noticed the square where Dani has asked me to meet him. Buildings enclose it on all sides. In the middle is an oval garden, with roses, a statue and a border of orange trees.

“There’s 18 of them,” he tells me. I am about to learn why the number matters. It is December 2022, and our meeting will take us from those trees to another square where he is planning a public Hanukkah celebration. Along the way, familiar streets become starting points for stories I have never heard.

A different way of looking at Palma

Dani explains that the Hebrew word chai, meaning life, is written with two letters whose numerical values add up to 18. That gives the number a particular significance. A charitable donation or a gift might be €18, or a multiple of it, expressing a wish for life and good fortune.

The orange trees were a gift from Jacqueline Tobias, who founded the Institute of Cultural Relations between Israel and the Balearic Islands. Dani tells me a plaque is due to mark that connection. What I had seen as a small garden now has another layer of meaning.

I grew up in north London near Jewish communities, but that proximity did not mean I understood the traditions or the faith. Talking to Dani gives me the opportunity to ask. He is used to making connections between people who know a subject well and people encountering it for the first time.

Finding Mallorca’s Jewish community

Dani had worked in television commercial production before becoming a Jewish educator. He came to Mallorca from New York in search of something different and, soon after arriving, met the woman who would become his wife and the mother of his son.

The move also changed his relationship with his own heritage. In New York, Jewish life had been around him. In Mallorca, he felt a need to seek it out.

“When I was in New York, I just took it for granted really,” he tells me. It was on the island that he realised he wanted, and needed, to connect with other Jewish people. He had not even known there was a Jewish community here.

Finding it meant learning about more than the lives of other people who had recently moved to Mallorca. There was a much longer history to understand, including persecution, forced conversion and families whose connections with the island stretched back through generations.

Dani’s heritage walks through Palma grew out of that interest in sharing what he had learnt. A street that looks ordinary to a passer-by can lead to a conversation about the people who once lived there and how their stories are remembered.

Why sharing Jewish history matters

As we walk, Dani talks about the Spanish Inquisition and the persecution of Jewish people. Families were forced to convert to Catholicism to protect themselves. Understanding that history changes how you look at the city, particularly if you have known its streets for years without hearing those accounts.

“Because how can we know where we’re going if we don’t know where we’re coming from?” he replies. He believes that knowing what happened before us is part of avoiding the repetition of it.

Bringing people together through Limud Mallorca

Dani and his wife founded the Mallorca branch of Limud as a Jewish cultural association. He describes an organisation intended to reach Jewish residents who feel disconnected from their heritage, families of mixed faiths and non-Jewish people interested in Jewish values and history.

The activities he lists are varied: documentary screenings, book presentations, choir concerts, lectures, seminars, celebrations and community Shabbat dinners. The dinners had taken place at different vegetarian restaurants around Mallorca.

Limud was run by volunteers, and at the time of our interview they were working with the city on cultural and social events. The Hanukkah gathering he was planning was one example of how that work could move into public space.

Planning a Hanukkah celebration in the square

We leave Plaça del Banc de s’Oli and walk to Plaça de Raimundo Clar. It is a larger space, with room for a stage and stalls. Dani stands in the centre, mentally arranging everything as he explains what he hopes people will find there.

He talks me through the meaning of Hanukkah. The eight-day festival recalls the rededication of the Temple in Jerusalem and the tradition of a small supply of oil lasting for eight days. Lighting candles, beginning with one and adding another each night, is part of remembering it.

For the celebration, the plans include the lighting of the first candle, a live klezmer performance and stalls introducing different parts of Jewish life. There will be books, jewellery and a stall exploring the connection between Mallorca’s olive oil trade and its medieval Jewish community and descendants.

Children will be able to make pop-up books and dreidels, the traditional spinning tops, and listen to stories. There will be jelly doughnuts, too. Dani talks about the possibility of leading some dancing, although he is leaving that decision until he sees how he feels on the night.

Making a home through connection

Dani arrived in Mallorca for a new chapter and found that reconnecting with his own culture gave him a way to contribute to the island. The work grew from a personal need to meet other Jewish people into tours and events that invite others to learn.

I cannot retell everything he shares during our walk. What stays with me is the way he makes a familiar city less familiar, and more interesting. Next time I pass those orange trees, I will count them. I will also think about how much there is to discover by asking someone why a place matters to them.

Find out about Palma’s Jewish heritage tours with Jewish Majorca.

Discover more lives and experiences in our At Home in Mallorca profiles, or explore the city through our guide to things to do in Palma.


This post may contain affiliate links that help support Majorca Mallorca in creating content like this. If you make a purchase using one of these links, Majorca Mallorca may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. Read our disclosure for more information.